Must-Try [12] Recipes-How To Make Mashed Potatoes With Mayonnaise

How To Make Mashed Potatoes With Mayonnaise? Stranged! Mashed potatoes are an ideal part of Thanksgiving. The only disadvantage with mashed potatoes is that they can be made in advance. And, if you store them in the fridge they get too hard and won’t be smooth anymore.

For the quick reference check the below recipes video.

You won’t believe how your mashed potatoes make a too thick, tasty, and creamy mayonnaise. Placing Mayonnaise in mashed potatoes may sound a little odd.

  • How to make mashed potatoes with eggs and mayonnaise
  • How do you use mayonnaise in mashed potatoes
  • How do you make mashed potatoes without mayonnaise
  • What is the mashed potato secret ingredient
  • Making mashed potatoes with mayo no butter
  • Instant mashed potatoes with mayo recipe
  • Mashed potatoes secret ingredients.
  • Best mashed potatoes recipe.

The mashed potatoes are not only tasty but are creamy also with various textures. The best part is that the mashed potato recipe with Mayonnaise is it gives you creamy flavor even after reheating.

Here is the step by step guide on how to make creamy mash potato:

How To Make Creamy Mash Potato?


  • Salt
  • Butter
  • Pepper
  • Potatoes
  • Mayonnaise
  • Milk or cream


  • Peels your potatoes before cooking and let them get cooked for 15-20 minutes.
  • Drain them after cooking
  • Melt some unsalted butter
  • Take milk or cream
  • Mash potatoes nicely and add butter and cream to it.
  • Take potatoes and butter mixture in a bowl and add Mayonnaise.
  • After mixing everything, season potatoes with salt and white pepper.

Also read below potatoes recipes.

What Is The Best Way To Make Mashed Potatoes From Scratch?

If you are looking for old mashed potatoes, you are in the right place. Here is the homestyle mashed potatoes recipe. The recipe can be followed with quite easy steps.

  • Prep time: 15 mins
  • Cook times: 20 mins

Ingredients: what to put in mashed potatoes

How To Make Mashed Potatoes With Mayonnaise
How To Make Mashed Potatoes With Mayonnaise
  • Peeled and baked potatoes
  • 2 tbsp butter
  • Milk
  • Salt and pepper


  • Carry a kettle to a boil with salted water. Put potatoes and let it boil for 15 minutes till they get soft and then let drain it.
  • Melt butter and boil milk on low steam in the saucepan. Add milk to the potatoes and mix it properly until it gets creamy.
  • You can use a potato masher or hands, just make sure it’s mixed properly. Then add pepper and salt.
See also  How To Make Plain Yogurt Taste Better [14 Best Ways]

Nutritional value: calories- 257, carbohydrates- 43.7g, fat- 7.2g and protein- 5.6g

What Can I Use As A Substitute For Milk In Mashed Potatoes?

For mashed potatoes, milk is not necessary. You just need a little amount of liquid to keep it wet. There are various choices to substitute for milk in mashed potatoes.

  • You should use the starchy water in which the potatoes are cooked. You can use water instead of starch water and will be good to use.
  • Dairy free milk mashed potatoes with mayo, especially if you like the flavor they add, can be a good substitute.

The following can be used as the substitute for butter in mashed potatoes:

  • Flavourful oils like olives, maize or grape seeds
  • Soy-free, margarine without milk
  • Healthy soy-free fat or shortening (usually based on the palm or coconut oil)

Can You Put Flour In Mashed Potatoes?

Yes, flour can be used in mashed potatoes.

Your mashed potatoes are watery for quite a few reasons. If you’re looking down at a white liquid bowl and wondering what went wrong, then here’s a fast fix.

It is the most popular way and easy way of thickening mashed potatoes. You can use flour and corn starch or milk as well as per you choice.

Mashed Potatoes With Eggs And Mayonnaise Recipe

If you are thinking how to make your mashed potatoes healthier? Here is the simple recipe of mashed potatoes with eggs and Mayonnaise.

  • Prep time: 40 minutes


How To Make Mashed Potatoes With Mayonnaise
How To Make Mashed Potatoes With Mayonnaise
  • Cheese
  • Cooked potatoes
  • Mayonnaise, 1 cup
  • Milk, one fourth cup
  • Two beaten eggs
  • Mustard, 2 tbsp
  • Sour cream, one and a half cup


  • Mash the mayo, sour cream, milk, eggs, and mustard with the potatoes.
  • Top with cheese and spoon into a greased pan.
  • You need to bake it at 350 degrees for half hour or you can also microwave it for 7 minutes.

How To Make Mayo Instant Mashed Potatoes?

Instant potatoes come in two distinct kinds: potato flakes and potato pearls. Cook and mash potatoes.

Once the potato flakes are prepared, leave them for drying, and then scrap them all. The essential part is to add water to potato flakes. 

It is also suggested to add butter, to get flavor and creaminess in the potatoes. Here is the recipe for mashed potatoes with mayo and sour cream:

  • Prep time: 5 mins
  • Cook time: 5 mins

Ingredients for mayo in mashed potatoes

How To Make Mashed Potatoes With Mayonnaise
How To Make Mashed Potatoes With Mayonnaise
  • Salted butter, 2 tbsp
  • Salt
  • Sour cream, one fourth
  • Potato flakes, two-third cup


  • Put the butter and salt in a small saucepan and bring it to a boil. Immediately remove it from the heat when it starts to boil.
  • Remove flakes of sour cream and potato, and combine with a fork. Make sure you moisten all the fragments, then let them stay until all the liquid is absorbed.
  • Put salt and pepper according to taste and you can also add on top the dollop of butter.

Nutritional value: calories- 233kcal, protein- 2g, carbohydrates- 17g, and fat- 17g.

Mashed Potatoes Without Mayonnaise

It can be tricky with mashed potatoes. They can get too thin or whipped too quickly, too thick or not dense enough.

And your taste depends on it! Here is the best-creamed potatoes recipe, making them fat, but smooth and fluffy.


  • Potatoes
  • Milk
  • Butter
  • Cream or cheese


  • Split a little larger (if boiling) the potatoes-Large potato dices will not get as mushy or soggy. It can also be avoided if the instant pot or crockpot is steamed or used.
  • Using stand mixer -Mash potatoes
  • Heat your milk before adding it to the potatoes. Heat your milk and butter. It will keep the potatoes warm, and even distribution will help.
  • Here you need to rinse all the water from the soft potatoes.
  • Peel and cut them into small pieces.
  • Boil potatoes again and before boiling clean and rinse them.
  • Creamy mashed potatoes – If you want creamy and dense potatoes then add cream or little cheese cream.

What Are The Mashed Potato Secret Ingredients?

If you are wondering how to make mashed potatoes creamier? Then here is something you would like.

See also  How To Cut A Steak [Exclusive 14 Slicing Tips] Like A Pro

Cream cheese is a hidden ingredient. Without overpowering the pure taste of the potatoes, cream cheese adds creaminess and a hint of tang.

And for perfect mashed potatoes, the second most essential tip: use a potato ricer! This guarantees an additional velvety texture without any lumps.


  • Potatoes
  • Unsalted butter, 3 tbsp
  • Cream, one third cup
  • Cream cheese


  • Peel potatoes and cut them in half and then place them in large pot with salted water.
  • Boil water by keeping pot on stove.
  • Now, let it boil for around 15 minutes and let them to become soft. Also, make sure to cover the pot.
  • While the potatoes are getting cooked, take a small pan. Keep it on medium-low flame and add cheese, butter and cream.
  • Cook the mixture until it becomes smooth and creamy.
  • Drain the potatoes, then move them into a wide bowl through a ricer until they are cool enough to treat. To the cup, add the massive cream mixture, stirring to blend. With salt and pepper, taste and season the potatoes.

Mashed Potatoes Without Butter Recipe

In the majority of mashed potato recipes, butter is the main ingredient, so it adds a large amount of fat to your dish.

But that doesn’t mean that by filling your body with butterfat, you can resist making mashed potatoes, or risk your wellbeing.

You can make amazing and creamy mashed potatoes without adding butter.Check out the replacements for butter in mashed potatoes recipe:

#1 Olive Oil:

First of all, drizzle 2 tbsp of olive oil on mashed potatoes instead of butter. Though fat is also contained in olive oil, it is unsaturated and good for your heart.

So, adding extra virgin olive oil is a better and healthier option for mashed potatoes. For a healthier option and a perfect replacement for butter, you can use a little more olive oil.

#2 Yogurt:

Another good substitute for butter is Greek yogurt in mashed potatoes. About half a cup of yogurt will give your recipe a creamy texture, without loading it with too much fat.

Moreover, a large dose of calcium and protein will also be added to your mashed potatoes, making them much better than buttered mashed potatoes.

#3 Cauliflowers Or Vegetables:

After mashing the potatoes, you could stir in some pureed cauliflower. Not only will it add a fluffy texture to your mashed potatoes.

But it will also add a mild and friendly cauliflower flavor to the most common recipe.

Adding it to your recipe will also get a lot of fiber, which will make your metabolism and bowel movements healthier.

#4 Butter Milk:

You can also replace high-fat butter with low-fat buttermilk for your homemade mashed potatoes recipe.

It’ll add cream and a touch of flavor to your potatoes, too. By adding fat-free or low-fat sour cream to the recipe as well, similar results can be obtained.

See also  How To Boil Peanuts- Healthy and Quick(#17) Boiled Peanut Recipes To Try

#5 Butternut Squash Puree:

Connect acorn or butternut squash puree to your mashed potatoes. Squash puree, just like cauliflower, will also give your potatoes a creamy texture, close to the creaminess that you achieve by adding butter.

While it can change your dish’s color, it improves the content of vitamin A and fiber, making it healthier and more nutritious.

These were the butter substitute for mashed potatoes recipes. You can use any substitute you like, or you can try all of them.

Hellmann’s Mayonnaise In Mashed Potatoes

The mashed potatoes with Mayonnaise are very creamy and are fantastic in taste as well. Here is a simple recipe:


  • Peeled potatoes
  • Hellmann’s Mayonnaise
  • Milk (optional)
  • Salt and pepper


  • Cover the potatoes in a 2-quart saucepan with water. Keep it on stove on high flame until it gets boiled.
  • Now, reduce the flame and let it get simmered till the potatoes get soft and then drain them.
  • Mash Potatoes
  • Stir in the Mayonnaise and milk from Hellmann.
  • If necessary, season it along with salt and black pepper.

Mashed Potato Casserole With Mayo Recipe

The best creamy, cheesy mashed potatoes ever! There’s extra melty cheese, crispy bacon, and chives in mashed potato casserole with mayo recipe easy-to-make side dish.

The best part is you can prepare it ahead of time. You can make this dish and then pop it in the oven to heat back up!


  • Potatoes
  • Cream butter
  • Sour cream
  • Milk
  • Garlic powder, optional
  • Salt
  • Cheese
  • Bread crumbs
  • Bacon
  • Chives


  • We’re going to start making mashed potatoes. We’re going to add sweet cream butter to the mashed potatoes, sour cream to make them extra creamy, a little milk, some garlic powder and salt to add flavour. It is optional, you can skip it if you don’t want.
  • Mix the mashed potatoes with some of the cheddar cheese. It helps make it extra cheesy for the whole dish.
  • Toast some panko bread crumbs and scatter them on top of them. They offer a lovely toasty flavour, plus they add a little texture.
  • Now, add some cheese and bread crumbs and then bake for few minutes.
  • Add the crumbled bacon and chives after baking. Serve warm this dish. It could be the highlight of the meal!

You may also like to read below recipes.


  • We have seen all the best recipes for How To Make Mashed Potatoes With Mayonnaise.
  • Mashed potatoes are considered one of the best for thanksgiving and liked by everyone.
  • You can try various recipes with the mashed potatoes depending on your choices.
  • It includes all your favorite ingredients such as cheese, cream, and butter. You can always try something new in the kitchen with mashed potatoes.

Did you find the How To Make Mashed Potatoes With Mayonnaise recipes interesting? Please follow Knifeandfork Pinterest and leave a comment below, share it, like it, rate it. We’d love to see what you cook! write to us Here. We, as a blogger, need all the help, motivation, and appreciation. This small help for Subscribing and sharing on social media will be appreciated!

Common questions on How To Make Mashed Potatoes With Mayonnaise?

Q1: How Many Calories Mashed Potatoes With Mayo Have? 

The mashed potatoes with mayo of 1 cup have 280 calories, 10g fat, 4g protein, and 41g carbohydrates. Using Hellmann’s Mayonnaise in mashed potatoes is one of the best substitutes for butter in mashed potatoes.

Q2: Mashed Potatoes With Mayonnaise Healthy Or Unhealthy

Although, boiled potatoes are a healthy option instead of fried ones. But when you combine Mashed Potatoes With Mayonnaise, it depends on how much amount you are putting in the recipe, makes it healthy or Unhealthy.